Assertion–Reason -The Price Puzzle : What Drives the Market

Instructions

For each question, choose the correct option:

A. Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
B. Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
C. Assertion (A) is true, but Reason (R) is false.
D. Assertion (A) is false, but Reason (R) is true.

Topic 1: Meaning of Demand

Q1.

Assertion (A): A student’s desire to buy an expensive laptop is not necessarily demand in the economic sense.

Reason (R): Demand requires both willingness and ability to buy at a particular price.

Q2.

Assertion (A): If a person has enough money to buy a product but does not want to buy it, the product is not part of that person’s demand.

Reason (R): Demand considers only the purchasing power of a person and not the person’s willingness to buy.

Q3.

Assertion (A): A consumer’s demand for a product can change when the price of that product changes.

Reason (R): Demand refers to the quantity a consumer is willing and able to buy at a particular price.

Q4.

Assertion (A): A person’s desire for a luxury car is always considered demand.

Reason (R): A desire becomes demand only when the person is both willing and able to purchase the product.

Q5.

Assertion (A): Two people with the same desire for a smartphone may have different effective demand for it.

Reason (R): Their ability to pay for the smartphone may be different.

Topic 2: Law of Demand

Q6.

Assertion (A): Generally, a fall in the price of a good increases its quantity demanded, other things remaining unchanged.

Reason (R): A lower price makes the good relatively more attractive to consumers and can allow them to buy more.

Q7.

Assertion (A): According to the Law of Demand, consumers always buy more of every good whenever its price falls.

Reason (R): The Law of Demand describes a general inverse relationship between price and quantity demanded, other things remaining unchanged.

Q8.

Assertion (A): If the price of a product rises, its quantity demanded generally falls, assuming other relevant factors remain unchanged.

Reason (R): A price change causes a movement along the existing demand relationship rather than necessarily changing consumers’ underlying preferences.

Q9.

Assertion (A): The Law of Demand can help a shopkeeper predict the likely effect of a price reduction.

Reason (R): The Law of Demand says that price and quantity demanded generally move in opposite directions, other things remaining unchanged.

Q10.

Assertion (A): A fall in the price of a good always proves that its demand curve has shifted to the right.

Reason (R): A change in the good’s own price generally changes quantity demanded rather than shifting the demand curve.

Topic 3: Demand Schedule and Demand Curve

Q11.

Assertion (A): A demand schedule can help convert information about different prices and quantities demanded into an organised form.

Reason (R): A demand schedule records quantities demanded at different prices.

Q12.

Assertion (A): A demand curve is useful for visually studying the relationship between price and quantity demanded.

Reason (R): A demand curve represents the relationship between price and quantity demanded graphically.

Q13.

Assertion (A): If a demand schedule shows that quantity demanded falls as price rises, its corresponding demand curve will generally slope downward.

Reason (R): The demand curve is based on the price–quantity relationship shown in the demand schedule.

Q14.

Assertion (A): Every point on a demand curve represents exactly the same quantity demanded.

Reason (R): Different points on a demand curve can represent different quantities demanded at different prices.

Q15.

Assertion (A): A demand curve can help a student understand why quantity demanded changes when the price changes.

Reason (R): It provides a visual representation of the relationship between price and quantity demanded.

Topic 4: Meaning of Supply

Q16.

Assertion (A): Supply is not simply the total amount of a product stored by a producer.

Reason (R): Economic supply is related to the quantity producers are willing and able to offer for sale at a particular price.

Q17.

Assertion (A): A producer may be willing to sell a product but may not supply an unlimited quantity of it at the same price.

Reason (R): Production and selling decisions can depend on the price and the producer’s ability to provide the product.

Q18.

Assertion (A): A producer’s willingness to sell a product is relevant when analysing supply.

Reason (R): Supply involves the quantity producers are willing and able to offer for sale.

Q19.

Assertion (A): If a producer owns a large stock of goods, the entire stock automatically becomes market supply.

Reason (R): Supply concerns the quantity offered for sale rather than merely the quantity physically possessed.

Q20.

Assertion (A): Supply can be affected by the price received by producers.

Reason (R): The price received provides an important signal for producers when deciding how much to offer for sale.

Topic 5: Law of Supply

Q21.

Assertion (A): Generally, producers are willing to supply more of a good when its price rises, other things remaining unchanged.

Reason (R): A higher price can make supplying additional units more attractive to producers.

Q22.

Assertion (A): The Law of Supply means producers must increase supply whenever price rises.

Reason (R): The law describes a general relationship between price and quantity supplied under other unchanged conditions.

Q23.

Assertion (A): A higher market price can encourage producers to offer more output for sale.

Reason (R): Producers may respond to the greater return associated with a higher price.

Q24.

Assertion (A): A fall in price necessarily causes the supply curve itself to shift left.

Reason (R): A change in the good’s own price generally causes a change in quantity supplied rather than a shift of the supply curve.

Q25.

Assertion (A): The Law of Supply is useful for analysing how producers may respond to price changes.

Reason (R): It describes a general positive relationship between price and quantity supplied, other things remaining unchanged.

Topic 6: Supply Schedule and Supply Curve

Q26.

Assertion (A): A supply schedule can show how much producers are willing to sell at different prices.

Reason (R): It lists quantities supplied corresponding to different prices.

Q27.

Assertion (A): A supply curve is generally upward sloping when the Law of Supply holds.

Reason (R): Higher prices are generally associated with higher quantities supplied, other things remaining unchanged.

Q28.

Assertion (A): Different points on a supply curve may show different quantities supplied.

Reason (R): Each point can represent a quantity supplied corresponding to a particular price.

Q29.

Assertion (A): A supply schedule and a supply curve can convey related economic information in different forms.

Reason (R): A schedule presents information in a table-like form, while a curve presents the relationship graphically.

Q30.

Assertion (A): A supply curve can help producers and students visualise the relationship between price and quantity supplied.

Reason (R): The curve shows how quantity supplied is related to price.

Topic 7: Equilibrium Price and Equilibrium Quantity

Q31.

Assertion (A): Market equilibrium occurs where quantity demanded equals quantity supplied.

Reason (R): At that point, the amount buyers want to purchase equals the amount sellers want to sell.

Q32.

Assertion (A): If quantity demanded is greater than quantity supplied at a given price, that price represents equilibrium.

Reason (R): Equilibrium requires equality between quantity demanded and quantity supplied.

Q33.

Assertion (A): Equilibrium price is determined by the interaction of demand and supply.

Reason (R): Both buyers’ willingness to purchase and sellers’ willingness to supply influence the market outcome.

Q34.

Assertion (A): At equilibrium, a market must have a shortage.

Reason (R): A shortage occurs when quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied.

Q35.

Assertion (A): If demand increases while supply remains unchanged, the equilibrium outcome can change.

Reason (R): A change in demand alters the point at which demand and supply are equal.

Topic 8: Surplus and Shortage

Q36.

Assertion (A): A shortage occurs when buyers want to purchase more than sellers are willing to provide at a particular price.

Reason (R): Quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied during a shortage.

Q37.

Assertion (A): A surplus can occur when sellers offer more than buyers want to purchase at the prevailing price.

Reason (R): A surplus means quantity supplied exceeds quantity demanded.

Q38.

Assertion (A): A shortage does not mean that consumers have no desire for the product.

Reason (R): A shortage means quantity demanded is greater than quantity supplied at the particular price.

Q39.

Assertion (A): If a market has a surplus, every consumer who wants the product must be unable to obtain it.

Reason (R): A surplus means sellers have offered more than buyers want to purchase at the prevailing price.

Q40.

Assertion (A): Surplus and shortage are useful concepts for understanding whether the prevailing price is consistent with market demand and supply.

Reason (R): They compare the quantities buyers want with the quantities sellers offer.

Topic 9: Changes in Demand and Their Effect on Equilibrium

Q41.

Assertion (A): An increase in demand, with supply unchanged, can raise the equilibrium price.

Reason (R): At the old price, buyers may want more than sellers are offering, creating upward pressure on price.

Q42.

Assertion (A): A fall in demand necessarily causes the supply curve to shift left.

Reason (R): A change in demand changes the demand side of the market rather than automatically changing supply conditions.

Q43.

Assertion (A): If more consumers want a product at the existing prices, the equilibrium outcome may change.

Reason (R): An increase in demand can create a situation where quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied at the old equilibrium price.

Q44.

Assertion (A): An increase in demand always lowers equilibrium price.

Reason (R): When demand increases and supply is unchanged, the new equilibrium generally involves a higher price.

Q45.

Assertion (A): Changes in demand can affect both equilibrium price and equilibrium quantity.

Reason (R): Equilibrium depends on the interaction of demand and supply.

Topic 10: Changes in Supply and Their Effect on Equilibrium

Q46.

Assertion (A): An increase in supply, with demand unchanged, can lower equilibrium price.

Reason (R): Greater supply can create downward pressure on price if demand does not increase correspondingly.

Q47.

Assertion (A): A reduction in supply can create a shortage at the old equilibrium price.

Reason (R): With less supply available, quantity supplied at the old price may become lower than quantity demanded.

Q48.

Assertion (A): An increase in supply necessarily means that consumers’ demand curve has shifted.

Reason (R): A change in supply concerns sellers’ conditions rather than automatically changing consumers’ demand.

Q49.

Assertion (A): A fall in supply can affect the equilibrium quantity traded in a market.

Reason (R): Equilibrium quantity is determined through the interaction of demand and supply.

Q50.

Assertion (A): If supply increases while demand remains unchanged, equilibrium quantity can increase.

Reason (R): More units can be supplied and traded when the market moves to a new equilibrium.

Topic 11: Real-World Deviations — Necessities, Luxury Goods, Perishables and Expectations

Q51.

Assertion (A): The response of consumers to price changes may be different for necessities and luxury goods.

Reason (R): Consumers may find it harder to reduce consumption of an essential item than to reduce consumption of a luxury item.

Q52.

Assertion (A): A household may continue buying a necessary medicine even after its price rises.

Reason (R): The medicine may be considered essential for the household.

Q53.

Assertion (A): Consumers’ expectations about future prices can influence their current buying decisions.

Reason (R): People may change current purchases when they expect prices to change in the future.

Q54.

Assertion (A): Perishable goods can never experience changes in supply or price.

Reason (R): Perishable goods have limited storage life and therefore sellers may have to respond quickly to market conditions.

Q55.

Assertion (A): A consumer expecting a large price increase in a product may decide to buy more of it today.

Reason (R): Expectations about future prices can influence present demand.

Topic 12: Price Ceilings and Shortages

Q56.

Assertion (A): A price ceiling set below the market equilibrium price can create a shortage.

Reason (R): At the controlled lower price, quantity demanded may exceed quantity supplied.

Q57.

Assertion (A): A price ceiling always increases the quantity supplied in a market.

Reason (R): A lower controlled price can reduce the incentive of some sellers to supply the product.

Q58.

Assertion (A): Government intervention through a price ceiling can affect how a market allocates a product.

Reason (R): When the controlled price is below equilibrium, the quantity demanded and supplied may no longer be equal.

Q59.

Assertion (A): A price ceiling above the equilibrium price necessarily creates a shortage.

Reason (R): A ceiling above the equilibrium price does not prevent the market from operating at its equilibrium price.

Q60.

Assertion (A): A price ceiling below equilibrium can create a gap between the quantity consumers want and the quantity producers offer.

Reason (R): The controlled price can make quantity demanded greater than quantity supplied.

Topic 13: Black Markets

Q61.

Assertion (A): A shortage created by a binding price ceiling can provide conditions in which black-market transactions may emerge.

Reason (R): Some buyers may be willing to pay more than the legal controlled price when the product is scarce.

Q62.

Assertion (A): Black markets can develop when legal market arrangements do not satisfy some buyers’ demand.

Reason (R): A shortage can create incentives for transactions outside the regulated market.

Q63.

Assertion (A): Every shortage automatically creates a black market.

Reason (R): Black-market activity can arise when scarcity, restrictions and incentives make unofficial transactions possible.

Q64.

Assertion (A): A black market is simply the normal legal market operating at a higher price.

Reason (R): Black-market transactions occur outside the legally permitted market arrangements.

Q65.

Assertion (A): If a controlled price creates a shortage, some consumers may search for alternative ways to obtain the scarce product.

Reason (R): Scarcity can increase the incentive to find a product through channels outside the regulated market.

Topic 14: Market Failures — Externalities and Information Asymmetry

Q66.

Assertion (A): A market outcome may fail to reflect some costs imposed on people who are not directly involved in a transaction.

Reason (R): An externality occurs when an economic activity affects third parties who are not directly part of the transaction.

Q67.

Assertion (A): Pollution from a factory can be an example of a negative externality.

Reason (R): Pollution can impose costs on nearby people even though they are not buyers or sellers in the factory’s transactions.

Q68.

Assertion (A): Information asymmetry means that all participants in a market have exactly the same information.

Reason (R): Information asymmetry exists when one side of a transaction has more or better information than the other side.

Q69.

Assertion (A): Information asymmetry can make it difficult for a buyer to judge the quality of a product.

Reason (R): The seller may possess information about product quality that the buyer does not have.

Q70.

Assertion (A): A market with information asymmetry must always produce an efficient outcome.

Reason (R): Unequal information can interfere with well-informed decisions by market participants.

Topic 15: Public Goods

Q71.

Assertion (A): Public goods can be difficult for private markets to provide in adequate amounts.

Reason (R): Public goods are generally characterised by non-excludability and non-rivalry.

Q72.

Assertion (A): Street lighting can have characteristics of a public good.

Reason (R): One person’s benefit from street lighting does not normally prevent others in the area from benefiting from the same lighting.

Q73.

Assertion (A): A public good is necessarily a good that only the government can produce.

Reason (R): The key economic characteristics of public goods are non-excludability and non-rivalry, not simply government ownership.

Q74.

Assertion (A): If one person’s use of a good substantially reduces the amount available for others, the good is non-rival.

Reason (R): Non-rival goods can be used by one person without reducing the ability of others to benefit from them.

Q75.

Assertion (A): Public goods may be under-provided by private markets.

Reason (R): Their non-excludable nature can make it difficult for private providers to charge every beneficiary.

DETAILED ANSWER KEY

Topic 1: Meaning of Demand

Q1 — A
Both statements are true, and the Reason directly explains the Assertion. Mere desire is not sufficient; effective demand requires willingness and ability to purchase.

Q2 — C
The Assertion is true because willingness is also necessary. The Reason is false because demand depends on both willingness and ability, not purchasing power alone.

Q3 — A
Both are true, and the Reason explains why the quantity demanded is considered at a particular price.

Q4 — D
The Assertion is false because desire alone is not always demand. The Reason is true because willingness and ability to buy are required.

Q5 — B
Both are true, but the Reason gives a specific factor—ability to pay—rather than fully explaining all possible differences in effective demand.

Topic 2: Law of Demand

Q6 — A
Both are true, and the Reason explains why a lower price generally encourages a higher quantity demanded.

Q7 — D
The Assertion is false because “always” is too absolute. The Reason correctly describes the Law of Demand as a general inverse relationship under other unchanged conditions.

Q8 — A
Both are true. A change in own price generally causes a movement along the demand relationship, while preferences and other determinants are assumed unchanged.

Q9 — A
Both are true, and the Reason directly explains why a price reduction may increase quantity demanded.

Q10 — D
The Assertion is false. A fall in own price normally changes quantity demanded rather than shifting the entire demand curve. The Reason is true.

Topic 3: Demand Schedule and Demand Curve

Q11 — A
A demand schedule records quantities demanded at different prices, so it directly provides the organised information described.

Q12 — A
Both statements are true, and the Reason directly explains the usefulness of the demand curve.

Q13 — A
The downward relationship in the schedule is represented graphically by a generally downward-sloping demand curve.

Q14 — D
The Assertion is false because different points represent different price–quantity combinations. The Reason is true.

Q15 — A
The curve visually represents the relationship between price and quantity demanded, making the relationship easier to interpret.

Topic 4: Meaning of Supply

Q16 — A
Supply is about the quantity producers are willing and able to offer for sale, not simply their physical stock.

Q17 — B
Both are true. However, the Reason gives the broader decision-making conditions rather than being a complete explanation of every reason why supply may be limited.

Q18 — A
Willingness to sell is an essential part of the economic concept of supply.

Q19 — D
The Assertion is false because possessing stock does not mean the entire stock is being offered for sale. The Reason is true.

Q20 — A
Price provides an important incentive and signal to producers and therefore can influence supply decisions.

Topic 5: Law of Supply

Q21 — A
A higher price can make additional production and sale more attractive, giving the positive relationship described by the Law of Supply.

Q22 — D
The Assertion is false because the law expresses a general relationship, not an absolute rule applying in every possible situation. The Reason is true.

Q23 — A
Both statements are true, and the higher return can explain why producers may offer more.

Q24 — D
The Assertion is false. A change in own price generally changes quantity supplied along the supply curve. The Reason is true.

Q25 — A
The Law of Supply directly helps analyse producers’ responses to price changes.

Topic 6: Supply Schedule and Supply Curve

Q26 — A
A supply schedule records quantities supplied at different prices, exactly as described.

Q27 — A
The upward slope represents the general positive relationship between price and quantity supplied.

Q28 — A
Different points correspond to different price and quantity-supplied combinations.

Q29 — A
Both are true, and the Reason directly explains how the two forms communicate related information.

Q30 — A
The supply curve gives a visual representation of the price–quantity supplied relationship.

Topic 7: Equilibrium Price and Equilibrium Quantity

Q31 — A
Equilibrium occurs when quantity demanded equals quantity supplied; the Reason states precisely why.

Q32 — D
The Assertion is false because excess demand represents a shortage, not equilibrium. The Reason correctly states the condition for equilibrium.

Q33 — A
Both sides of the market interact to determine the equilibrium outcome.

Q34 — D
The Assertion is false because equilibrium means equality, not shortage. The Reason correctly defines shortage.

Q35 — A
A change in demand changes the relationship between demand and supply and therefore can change the equilibrium outcome.

Topic 8: Surplus and Shortage

Q36 — A
A shortage is precisely the situation where quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied.

Q37 — A
A surplus occurs when quantity supplied exceeds quantity demanded.

Q38 — A
The Assertion is true because shortage concerns the comparison of desired purchases with available supply, not the absence of desire. The Reason correctly defines shortage.

Q39 — D
The Assertion is false. A surplus does not mean consumers cannot obtain the product; rather, sellers have more than buyers want at that price. The Reason is true.

Q40 — A
Surplus and shortage compare the two sides of the market and therefore help analyse the market situation.

Topic 9: Changes in Demand and Their Effect on Equilibrium

Q41 — A
An increase in demand can create excess demand at the old price, putting upward pressure on price.

Q42 — D
The Assertion is false because a fall in demand does not automatically shift the supply curve. The Reason is true.

Q43 — A
More consumers wanting the product can increase demand and create excess demand at the previous equilibrium price.

Q44 — D
The Assertion is false because increased demand generally puts upward rather than downward pressure on equilibrium price when supply is unchanged. The Reason is true.

Q45 — B
Both are true, but the Reason states the general basis of equilibrium rather than specifically explaining why a demand change can affect both price and quantity.

Topic 10: Changes in Supply and Their Effect on Equilibrium

Q46 — A
Greater supply can create downward pressure on price when demand remains unchanged.

Q47 — A
Reduced supply can make quantity supplied lower than quantity demanded at the old price, creating a shortage.

Q48 — D
The Assertion is false. An increase in supply does not mean that demand has shifted. The Reason is true.

Q49 — B
Both statements are true, but the Reason is a general statement about equilibrium rather than a direct explanation of the specific effect of falling supply.

Q50 — A
With greater supply and unchanged demand, the market can move to an equilibrium involving a larger quantity traded.

Topic 11: Real-World Deviations

Q51 — A
Necessities are often harder to reduce in consumption than luxury goods, so consumers may respond differently to price changes.

Q52 — A
Both statements are true, and the essential nature of medicine explains why a household may continue purchasing it.

Q53 — A
Expectations about future prices can directly affect present purchasing decisions.

Q54 — D
The Assertion is false. Perishable goods can experience changes in supply and price. The Reason is true because limited storage life makes quick responses important.

Q55 — A
Expectation of a future price increase can encourage consumers to purchase earlier, increasing current demand.

Topic 12: Price Ceilings and Shortages

Q56 — A
A binding price ceiling below equilibrium can make quantity demanded greater than quantity supplied, creating a shortage.

Q57 — D
The Assertion is false because a lower controlled price does not necessarily increase supply. The Reason correctly explains why supply may decrease.

Q58 — A
A binding price ceiling changes the price at which transactions are permitted and can therefore create a gap between demand and supply.

Q59 — D
The Assertion is false. A ceiling above equilibrium is not binding and therefore does not necessarily create a shortage. The Reason is true.

Q60 — A
A binding ceiling can create exactly the stated gap: consumers want more than sellers offer at the controlled price.

Topic 13: Black Markets

Q61 — A
A shortage combined with a legally restricted price can create incentives for unofficial transactions at higher prices.

Q62 — A
When legal supply does not satisfy demand, some participants may have an incentive to use unofficial channels.

Q63 — D
The Assertion is false because a shortage does not automatically guarantee a black market. The Reason correctly identifies conditions that can encourage one.

Q64 — D
The Assertion is false because a black market involves transactions outside legally permitted market arrangements. The Reason is true.

Q65 — A
Scarcity can encourage consumers to seek alternative channels when normal regulated channels cannot meet their demand.

Topic 14: Market Failures

Q66 — A
An externality occurs when an economic activity affects third parties outside the direct transaction.

Q67 — A
Pollution can impose costs on people who are neither buyers nor sellers in the factory’s transactions.

Q68 — D
The Assertion is false. Information asymmetry means information is unevenly distributed, not equally available. The Reason is true.

Q69 — A
A seller’s superior information about product quality can make it difficult for a buyer to judge that quality accurately.

Q70 — D
The Assertion is false because information asymmetry can prevent well-informed decisions. The Reason is true.

Topic 15: Public Goods

Q71 — A
The characteristics of non-excludability and non-rivalry can make it difficult for private providers to charge all beneficiaries, contributing to under-provision.

Q72 — A
Street lighting can benefit multiple people simultaneously without one person’s use normally reducing another person’s benefit.

Q73 — D
The Assertion is false. Public goods are defined by their economic characteristics, not simply by government ownership. The Reason is true.

Q74 — D
The Assertion is false because if one person’s use reduces availability for others, the good is rival, not non-rival. The Reason correctly defines non-rivalry.

Q75 — A
Non-excludability can make charging individual users difficult, which can contribute to under-provision by private markets.

TABULAR ANSWER KEY

Q.Ans.Q.Ans.Q.Ans.Q.Ans.Q.Ans.
1A16A31A46A61A
2C17B32D47A62A
3A18A33A48D63D
4D19D34D49B64D
5B20A35A50A65A
6A21A36A51A66A
7D22D37A52A67A
8A23A38A53A68D
9A24D39D54D69A
10D25A40A55A70D
11A26A41A56A71A
12A27A42D57D72A
13A28A43A58A73D
14D29A44D59D74D
15A30A45B60A75A